Every few years, it seems, the same extraordinary idea resurfaces along the Côte d’Azur: a new underground railway linking Nice Airport with Monaco, continuing through Menton and potentially reaching Ventimiglia in Italy.
This time, however, the proposal has returned with a considerably larger price tag and a more developed technical case. The latest concept puts the cost at approximately €5.8 billion and envisages a 14-station automated underground system stretching from Nice Airport through the Riviera and into Italy.
It remains far from becoming a construction project, but its return highlights a problem that is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore: how to move growing numbers of people between Nice, Monaco, Menton and the Italian border through one of Europe’s most constrained coastal corridors.
An idea that keeps coming back
The Nice–Monaco metro is not a new concept. Versions of the proposal have appeared repeatedly over the years, generally disappearing after political or financial objections before eventually resurfacing.
The Nice–Monaco metro is not a new concept. Versions of the proposal have appeared repeatedly over the years, generally disappearing after political or financial objections before eventually resurfacing.
The latest version is particularly notable because it has been developed beyond a simple vision for a new railway. The Fédération des Entreprises Monégasques (FEDEM) has commissioned a preliminary study examining possible routes, stations, costs, financing and potential economic benefits.
That gives the idea more substance than some earlier proposals, although it remains just that: a proposal.
France’s Transport Minister dismissed the concept in 2025, with the government arguing that the cost and complexity were difficult to justify when improvements to the existing railway could provide additional capacity. That position remains an important obstacle to the project moving forward.
From Nice Airport to Italy
The proposed automated railway would connect Nice Airport with major parts of Nice before continuing towards Monaco, Menton and Ventimiglia.
The 14 proposed stations include Nice Airport, Allianz Riviera, Nice-Nord and Nice-Pasteur, followed by several stops in Monaco, including Sainte-Dévote, the tourist office area, Larvotto–Place des Moulins and Parc Saint-Roman.
From Monaco, the line would continue east towards Carnolès, Menton and ultimately Ventimiglia.
The result would be considerably more than another railway connection to Monaco. It would create a high-frequency underground transport corridor linking one of the region’s major airports with Monaco and the communities on either side of the Franco-Italian border.
A 23-minute journey from Nice Airport to Monaco
The headline attraction is speed.
The headline attraction is speed.
Under the proposed system, the journey between Nice Airport and Monaco could take approximately 23 minutes, while some journeys from Nice to Monaco could take little more than 10 minutes. During peak periods, trains could operate at roughly five-minute intervals.
For commuters, that would represent a significant change.
The existing railway already provides an essential alternative to driving, but passengers traveling along the coast still face crowded trains, delays and the limitations of infrastructure squeezed between the Mediterranean and the mountains. Roads face their own problems, particularly during peak commuting periods.
An underground system would create another major transport artery rather than simply attempting to squeeze more capacity out of the existing corridor.
Why Monaco is looking for another solution
The underlying issue is closely connected to Monaco’s extraordinary concentration of economic activity within a very small territory.
The underlying issue is closely connected to Monaco’s extraordinary concentration of economic activity within a very small territory.
Thousands of people working in the Principality live in surrounding French and Italian communities because Monaco has limited residential capacity. As the Principality continues to attract businesses, employees and investment, the number of people traveling into Monaco becomes an increasingly important infrastructure issue.
FEDEM has suggested that Monaco could potentially reach approximately 100,000 jobs by 2070. Whether that projection ultimately proves accurate is impossible to know, but it illustrates the long-term challenge facing the Principality.
Monaco cannot accommodate all of its economic growth within its own borders. It therefore depends heavily on the surrounding Riviera for housing, workers and transportation.
That makes the connection between Nice, Monaco, Menton and Italy an economic issue as much as a transportation one.
The €5.8 billion question
The latest proposal carries an estimated price of approximately €5.6 billion to €5.8 billion.
The latest proposal carries an estimated price of approximately €5.6 billion to €5.8 billion.
FEDEM’s study envisages a mixture of public funding, public investment, borrowing and private capital rather than expecting a single government to finance the entire project. It also projects substantial long-term revenues from passenger services and other uses of the infrastructure.
Those figures, however, are projections rather than guaranteed financial results.
There is a considerable difference between producing a preliminary financial model and securing the agreement of governments, infrastructure authorities, lenders and private investors to commit billions of euros.
For that reason, the €5.8 billion figure should not be interpreted as the confirmed cost of a project that is ready to enter construction. No final financing agreement or construction contract currently exists.
Why France remains skeptical
The French government’s argument is relatively straightforward: improve the transport infrastructure already in place before spending billions on an entirely new underground railway.
The French government’s argument is relatively straightforward: improve the transport infrastructure already in place before spending billions on an entirely new underground railway.
The existing TER network between Cannes and Menton has already benefited from increased service frequency, while additional rolling stock, signalling improvements and the planned Azur regional express network are intended to increase capacity further.
From Paris’s perspective, those investments are easier to justify than building a completely new underground system.
Time is another factor. A project of this scale could require years of studies, approvals and preparation followed by a decade or more of construction. Estimates have suggested a development period of around 15 to 20 years or potentially longer.
The debate therefore comes down to a familiar infrastructure question: should governments continue expanding and modernizing the existing network, or invest in an entirely new system designed to meet demand several decades into the future?
Monaco’s argument is about the future
For Monaco and the businesses represented by FEDEM, improving the existing railway may not ultimately be sufficient.
For Monaco and the businesses represented by FEDEM, improving the existing railway may not ultimately be sufficient.
Their argument is that transport infrastructure should be planned for the Riviera of 2040, 2050 and beyond rather than designed solely around today’s demand.
If the number of people commuting into Monaco continues to increase, the existing road and rail corridors could eventually reach practical limits. A new underground system would therefore be viewed as long-term economic infrastructure serving Monaco and the wider French and Italian communities.
There could also be environmental benefits. If the metro attracted large numbers of commuters away from cars, it could reduce congestion and potentially lower transport-related emissions while making journeys into Monaco more predictable.
It would not replace the TER
The proposed metro is not necessarily intended to replace the existing railway.
The proposed metro is not necessarily intended to replace the existing railway.
Instead, the two systems could perform different roles. The TER could continue providing regional services, while the automated metro would handle a much more frequent flow of passengers between major urban centres.
FEDEM’s concept has also explored the possibility of using the underground infrastructure for overnight freight, potentially giving the system another economic function beyond passenger transport.
That would make the proposal considerably more ambitious than simply building a faster commuter railway.
The importance of Italy
The proposed connection to Ventimiglia is particularly significant because Monaco’s workforce does not come exclusively from France.
The proposed connection to Ventimiglia is particularly significant because Monaco’s workforce does not come exclusively from France.
Italy forms an important part of the Principality’s wider labour market, and a more efficient rail connection could make commuting from the Italian Riviera considerably easier.
It could also strengthen the economic relationship between Monaco, Menton and Liguria.
There has even been discussion of eventually extending the concept further into Italy towards Sanremo and Imperia, although that is not part of the principal 14-station proposal currently being discussed.
For now, Ventimiglia is the proposed endpoint.
Could it actually happen?
There is still a very long road between a preliminary study and construction.
There is still a very long road between a preliminary study and construction.
France has previously rejected the concept in favour of improving existing infrastructure. Monaco has shown interest in studying the proposal but has not committed to building it, while Italy would need to become directly involved if the line were to cross the border into Ventimiglia.
Then come the practical challenges: planning approvals, environmental assessments, tunneling, safety requirements, cross-border regulation, financing, engineering risks and construction.
Those hurdles mean the project should not be confused with an imminent construction program.
Why the idea refuses to disappear
There is something almost amusing about the recurring cycle.
There is something almost amusing about the recurring cycle.
A new study appears. Business leaders promote the concept. Politicians discuss it. Critics question the cost. France points towards improving the existing railway. The proposal gradually disappears from the headlines — and then, several years later, it returns.
But the reason it keeps coming back is perhaps more important than the proposal itself.
Nice continues to grow. Monaco continues to attract businesses and workers. Roads along the coast remain under pressure. The railway is increasingly important to the region, while Menton and the Italian border remain closely connected to Monaco’s economy.
The proposed metro may repeatedly disappear from the political agenda, but the transportation pressures that created the idea remain.
That is why the concept continues to resurface.
A project for the next Riviera
The €5.8 billion proposal deserves both enthusiasm and skepticism.
The €5.8 billion proposal deserves both enthusiasm and skepticism.
The prospect of traveling from Nice Airport to Monaco in approximately 23 minutes, continuing towards Menton and eventually crossing into Italy without relying on the heavily congested coastal roads is certainly compelling.
But the scale of the investment means that enthusiasm alone cannot justify construction. A project taking 15 or 20 years to develop would need to demonstrate that its long-term economic, environmental and social benefits outweigh the enormous financial and engineering challenges.
For now, the Nice–Monaco metro remains a remarkably ambitious proposal rather than an approved project.
Yet its repeated return is telling. Every couple of years, the idea comes back because the problem it is designed to solve never really goes away.
And that probably means this won’t be the last time the €5.8 billion Nice–Monaco metro makes headlines.


No comments:
Post a Comment